Rotherham United: Player ratings from the Millers v Charlton Athletic clash

Rotherham's best performer, Jon Taylor
Rotherham's best performer, Jon Taylor
Share this article

The Star’s Millers man, Paul Davis, assessess the performances at AESSEAL New York Stadium.

ROTHERHAM (4-4-2)

RICHARD O’DONNELL 6

One decent save to keep out a Ricky Holmes curler just before the break.

JOSH EMMANUEL 5

Made a bright start to his Rotherham United career but his inexperience is being exposed.

SEMI AJAYI 5

His mistake led to Charlton’s opener and he missed with two headers at the other end. Talented but flaky.

MICHAEL IHIEKWE 6

A footballing centre-half. The pick of a Millers defence which is lacking an organiser and a leader.

JOE MATTOCK 6

Crossing not to its usual standard. One of many Millers not at their best.

RYAN WILLIAMS 4

Never in the match and complained he had no energy. Boss Paul Warne was right to replace him at half-time.

DARREN POTTER 5

His poorest showing since arriving at New York Stadium in the summer. Couldn’t get the Millers going.

LEE FRECKLINGTON 5

Another who struggled to impose himself as Rotherham were beaten in midfield.

JOE NEWELL 4

After a couple of early crosses, he did nothing to affect the game.

KIEFFER MOORE 6

The big man worked hard and set up Jamie Proctor early on. Poor decision not to play in his strike partner after the interval.

JAMIE PROCTOR 6

Guilty of a bad miss but was having some success against two strong centre-halves before disaster struck.

Substitutes:

JON TAYLOR 7

Rotherham’s most dangerous player after coming on at half-time for Ryan Williams. Full of energy and attacked Charlton.

WILL VAULKS 5

On for Josh Emmanuel after 56 minutes. Hit the ball long too often.

JONSON CLARKE-HARRIS 5

Replaced Jamie Proctor with 20 minutes remaining. No real impact.

Subs not used: Bilboe, Forde, Purrington, Cummings.

Charlton (4-2-3-1): Amos 8; Solly 7, Bauer 9, Pearce 8, Dasilva 7; Kashi 6, Forster-Caskey 6; Fosu 6 (Ahearne-Grant 85), Clarke (Novak 85) 6, Holmes 9 (Konsa 89); Magennis 7. Subs not used: Phillips, Sarr, Crofts, Jackson.

Goals: Bauer 16, Magennis 66 (Charlton).

Referee: Trevor Kettle (Leicestershire) 4.

Attendance: 7,976 (520).

Match verdict: Proctor pain as Kettle has Millers steaming again